The Witch: What We Actually Know About Freida McFadden’s October Book

There is a new Freida McFadden on 6 October 2026, and for once the interesting thing is not the twist. It is that this book does not look like the other thirty.

The Witch has a haunted house in it. The jacket copy promises a grandfather clock that stops at 3:41 in the morning, lights that will not behave, and a voice crying for help outside a bedroom door. After a decade of books where the monster was a husband, a landlord or a boss, she has written one where the trouble may not be a person at all.

Here is the truth: this is the first time she has stepped outside the thing she is known for. Whether that is exciting or alarming probably depends on why you read her in the first place.

The Reader’s Truth: “The riskiest book an author writes is the one their readers did not order.”

---

What it is about

Julia Barlow has lost her job and her apartment. So she does what people in these books always do, which is go back to the house.

The house is Pemberton — her family’s seventeenth-century estate in rural Massachusetts, where her ageing grandmother needs looking after. It is large, it is old, and it is free, which is the only thing she needs it to be right now.

Then the clock starts stopping at 3:41 a.m. The lights flicker. Somebody, somewhere in the building, is crying for help.

When Julia starts digging into what Pemberton actually is, she finds a woman who was executed for witchcraft in 1692 — and a family that has spent a very long time deciding what not to say out loud.

The book runs two timelines — Julia in the present, and the woman accused in 1692. That is the whole setup, and it is all the publisher is giving away. US editions list it at 352 pages; the UK exclusive hardback is 320.

---

Massachusetts, 1692 is not a decorative detail

If you pick 1692 and rural Massachusetts, you have picked Salem, and you have picked it on purpose.

Over a few months that year, nineteen people were hanged in Salem for witchcraft. One more, an eighty-one-year-old farmer named Giles Corey, refused to enter a plea at all and was pressed to death under stones — the only death by pressing in the history of Massachusetts. At least five more died in custody, including a baby. Twenty-five people in total.

The belief itself was real. These were people who took witchcraft entirely seriously, and historians are clear that it is a mistake to treat that as a cover story. What the grudges decided was not whether there were witches but who got named — and there the land disputes, the unpaid debts and the question of which neighbours could be believed about which other neighbours did an enormous amount of work. The accusations moved through families.

So a novel that puts a woman executed in 1692 underneath a house full of family lies is not reaching for atmosphere. It is reaching for the part of Salem that still unsettles people, which is not the witches. It is what a community — and a family — will let happen to one of its own.

Whether the book does anything with that is the part none of us know yet.

---

The quiet thing: she is moving into hardback

Her books have gone out as paperback originals almost without exception. Cheap, fast, stacked by the till, designed to be bought on impulse and finished on a flight. That is a large part of how she got where she is. (Signed limited hardbacks have appeared before through retailers — this is the first time a hardback is the main event.)

The Witch is coming in hardback, with a deluxe edition alongside it, and her publisher is running a preorder campaign with signed copies and a launch event.

That is a publisher treating a book as an event rather than a restock. It usually means one of two things: they think this is her best, or they think the audience is now big enough that it does not matter. Possibly both.

Worth knowing before you see the price. The UK exclusive hardback is £22, which is a different proposition from the £9 paperbacks.

---

Should you preorder it?

Honest answer: it depends whether you like her or like the thing she does.

If you read her for the domestic thriller machinery — the ordinary house, the ordinary marriage, the floor giving way in chapter forty — this may not be that. Supernatural elements change the rules. When anything can be a ghost, the “wait, what” moment lands differently, and some readers find that it stops landing at all.

If you have started finding her books samey, this is the most promising thing she has published in years. Four in a row will show you the seams, as we said in our guide to reading her in order. A book that breaks the pattern is exactly what that problem needs.

If you are new to her, do not start here. Start with The Housemaid and find out whether you get on with how she writes, because a first book by an author is not the moment to also be testing a new genre on yourself.

If you want to wait two weeks and read the reviews — that is a completely reasonable plan and nobody will take your bookish card away.

---

One thing we are not going to do

We have not read it. Nobody outside the publisher has.

So this is not a review, and we are not going to tell you it is her best work or a bold reinvention or any of the other things that get written about books three weeks before they exist. Those posts are written from a press release, and you can always tell.

If you read it before we do, the comments are open. One reader saying which of her books they have already read and how this one compares is worth more than anything written three weeks early.

---

The short version

• The Witch, out 6 October 2026 from Poisoned Pen Press (Sourcebooks), 352 pages
• Standalone — no series, nothing to read first
• Julia Barlow, a family house called Pemberton, and a woman executed for witchcraft in 1692
• Her first hardback release, with a deluxe edition and a signed preorder campaign
• New for her: supernatural elements, which is the reason to be curious and the reason to be cautious

If you want the rest of the backlist sorted out first, we have done that here — and if you are wondering who she actually is now that she has given up the pen name, that story is worth ten minutes on its own.

---

Are you preordering this one, or waiting to see? I am curious how many of her readers actually want the ghost.

---

Sources: The Witch, on Freida McFadden’s official site · The Witch at Waterstones (publisher, date, format, price) · The Bookseller on the move into hardback · Sourcebooks preorder campaign · Peabody Essex Museum on the Salem witch trials · Library of Congress on the death of Giles Corey · History of Massachusetts on what actually caused the trials